Voted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay Pizzeria

Voted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay PizzeriaVoted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay PizzeriaVoted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay Pizzeria

Temporarily closed for an undetermined period due to Staffing shortages 

Call Now

(231) 866-4494

Voted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay Pizzeria

Voted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay PizzeriaVoted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay PizzeriaVoted Best Pizza in Suttons Bay MI! - Bay Pizzeria

Temporarily closed for an undetermined period due to Staffing shortages 

Call Now

(231) 866-4494

Our Philosophy

Pepperoni pizza slice on a white plate with fresh tomatoes and pasta.

Quality Ingredients

At Bay Pizzeria, located in Suttons Bay, we believe that quality ingredients make the best pizza. That's why our menu features only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients. From our handmade dough to our house-made sauce, to our unique one-of-a-kind offerings such as Cudighi Sausage, we put care and attention into every step of crafting our pizza's and sandwiches. 

We got our start in Michigan's Upper Peninsula, both our Co-Owner and Manager are original "Yooper's" and create pasties and cudighi straight from family recipes and learning from Yoopers in the kitchen. Our recipes are created with heart, soul, and honor to the past.

A Slice of Happiness: See Bay Pizzeria's Handcrafted food in Pictures

    Menu

    Pizza

    At Bay Pizzeria, you can enjoy a variety of crust flavors including Olive Oil, Butter, Garlic, Parmesan, Italian Herb, and Red Pepper Flake, all featured on our menu and at no additional cost, making your pizza experience even more delightful.

    Deluxe (Traditional Crust) 14"

    21

    Pepperoni, Ham, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, and Bacon.

    Deluxe (Traditional Crust) 16"

    23

    Pepperoni, Ham, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Peppers, and Bacon.

    Meat Lovers (Traditional Crust) 14"

    25

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Meatballs and our famous Cudighi.

    Meat Lovers (Traditional Crust) 16"

    27

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Meatballs and our famous Cudighi.

    BBQ Chicken 14"

    23

    Sweet Baby Ray's with fresh cut red onions and oven roasted chicken.

    BBQ Chicken 16"

    26

    Sweet Baby Ray's with fresh cut red onions and oven roasted chicken.

    Chicken Alfredo 14"

    23

    Alfredo sauce, oven roasted chicken and green peppers.

    Chicken Alfredo 16"

    26

    Alfredo sauce, oven roasted chicken and green peppers.

    Cheese (Traditional Crust) 16"

    15

    Cheese (Traditional Crust) 14"

    13

    Cheese (Pan Crust) 14"

    16

    Cheese (Gluten Friendly) 14"

    16

    Toppings and Meats

    Pepperoni

    2

    Sausage

    2

    Ham

    2

    Bacon

    2

    Meatball

    2

    Gyro Meat

    2

    Anchovies

    2

    Cudighi

    2

    Italian Sausage with origins in the U.P. is a beloved 'Yooper' classic. This unique dish can only be found in the U.P. and here.

    Mushroom

    1

    Red Onion

    1

    Green Pepper

    1

    Black Olive

    1

    Green Olive

    1

    Banana Pepper

    1

    Pineapple

    1

    Jalapeno

    1

    Tomato

    1

    Roasted Red Pepper

    1

    Feta

    1

    Spinach

    1

    Breadsticks and Cheese Bread

    Breadsticks (Small)

    8

    Enjoy 8 delicious breadsticks served with marinara sauce.

    Breadsticks (Large)

    10

    Enjoy 12 delicious breadsticks served with marinara sauce.

    Cheese Bread (Small)

    9

    2 Piece 

    Cheese Bread (Large)

    11

    4 Piece 

    Sandwiches

    Our take on some classics, thoughtfully and carefully crafted one at a time.

    Our Famous Cudighi Sandwich

    14

    Cudighi, Marinara, Mozzarella, Parmesan, Red Pepper, Green Pepper, Red Onion. This is our take on the Upper Peninsula sandwich found only in the U.P. and here at Bay Pizzeria in Suttons Bay! 

    Meatball Sub

    14

    When you're craving delicious meatballs topped with marinara, mozzarella, and parmesan, look no further than Bay Pizzeria. 

    Club Sub

    13

    Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Provolone, Colby, Red Onion, Mayo and Romaine. 

    Turkey Sub

    12

    Turkey, Swiss cheese, Tomato and Romaine lettuce, all topped with mayo.

    Ham Sub

    12

    Ham, Colby cheese, fresh Romaine, Roma tomatoes, and mayo. 

    Pizza Sub

    13

    Salami, pepperoni, ham, and our signature pizza cheese blend, all smothered in rich pizza sauce and complemented by delicious mushrooms. 

    Italian Sub

    13

    Salami, ham, romaine, Roma tomatoes, provolone cheese, red onion, and banana pepper rings, all tossed in Italian dressing. 

    Calzones

    Handcrafted one at a time.

    Cheese

    12

    Toppings are priced at $0.50, while meats on the Bay Pizzeria menu cost $1.00.

    Salads

    We offer fresh made salads as you wait.

    Garden

    13

    Enjoy fresh Romaine, Tomato, Carrot, Croutons, and a variety of Assorted Dressings.

    Caesar

    13

    Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons, and a delicious Caesar dressing.

    Greek

    14

    Romaine, Spinach, Black Olive, Onion, Roasted Red Pepper, Banana Pepper, Feta, and a delicious Greek dressing.

    Chicken Caesar

    15

    Romaine, Parmesan, Oven roasted Chicken, Croutons, and a delicious Caesar dressing.

    Delivery within 10 miles from Bay Pizza Suttons Bay is just $4.99! Please remember to tip your delivery driver, as they are dedicated to bringing the freshest pie from our Bay Pizzeria menu right to you. Thank you!

    Visit Us

    Special Requests?

    Do you have dietary concerns or questions about our menu or an upcoming event? Drop us a line, and we'll get back to you soon. 

    Bay Pizzeria

    100 South Cedar Street, Suttons Bay, Michigan 49682, United States

    (231) 866-4494

    Hours

    Today

    Closed

    Temporarily closed 

    Contact Us

    Attach Files
    Attachments (0)

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Cancel

    Connect With Us

    Copyright © 2026 Bay Pizzeria - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    This website uses cookies.

    We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

    Accept