More

Welcome to Bay Pizzeria

Welcome to Bay PizzeriaWelcome to Bay PizzeriaWelcome to Bay Pizzeria

From family dinners to game nights, we've got you covered!

We also offer delivery within 10 miles!

Order Now

(231) 866-4494

Welcome to Bay Pizzeria

Welcome to Bay PizzeriaWelcome to Bay PizzeriaWelcome to Bay Pizzeria

From family dinners to game nights, we've got you covered!

We also offer delivery within 10 miles!

Order Now

(231) 866-4494

Our Philosophy

Quality Ingredients

At Bay Pizzeria, we believe that quality ingredients make the best pizzas. That's why we use only the freshest, locally-sourced ingredients in our pizzas. From our handmade dough to our house made sauce, we put care and attention into every step of the process.

A Slice of Happiness: See Bay Pizzeria's Handcrafted food in Pictures

    Menu

    Pizza

    Crust Flavors are Olive Oil, Butter, Garlic, Parmesan, Italian Herb, Red Pepper Flake

    Deluxe (Traditional Crust) 14"

    21

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Pepper

    Deluxe (Traditional Crust) 16"

    23

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Mushrooms, Onions, Green Pepper

    Meat Lovers (Traditional Crust) 14"

    25

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Cudighi, Meatball

    Meat Lovers (Traditional Crust) 16"

    27

    Pepperoni, Ham, Bacon, Sausage, Cudighi, Meatball

    Cheese (Traditional Crust) 14"

    13

    Cheese (Traditional Crust) 16"

    15

    Cheese (Pan Crust) 14"

    16

    Cheese (Gluten Friendly) 14"

    16

    We use King Arthur flour for our crust and eggs

    Toppings and Meats

    Pepperoni

    2

    Sausage

    2

    Ham

    2

    Bacon

    2

    Meatball

    2

    Gyro Meat

    2

    Anchovies

    2

    Cudighi

    2

    Italian Sausage with origins in the U.P. This is a "Yooper" classic found only in the U.P and here!

    Mushroom

    1

    Onion

    1

    Green Pepper

    1

    Black Olive

    1

    Green Olive

    1

    Banana Pepper

    1

    Pineapple

    1

    Jalapeno

    1

    Tomato

    1

    Roasted Red Pepper

    1

    Feta

    1

    Spinach

    1

    Breadsticks and Cheese Bread

    Breadsticks (Small)

    8

    8 Breadsticks and Marinara

    Breadsticks (Large)

    10

    12 Breadsticks and Marinara

    Cheese Bread (Small)

    9

    2 Piece

    Cheese Bread (Large)

    11

    4 Piece

    Sandwiches

    Our take on some classics

    Cudighi Sandwich

    14

    Cudighi, Marinara, Mozzarella, Parmesan, Red Pepper, Green Pepper, Onion. 

    This is our take on the Upper Peninsula sandwich found only in the U.P and here!

    Meatball Sub

    14

    Meatballs, Marinara, Mozzarella, Parmesan

    Club Sub

    13

    Turkey, Ham, Bacon, Provolone, Colby, Red Onion, Romaine, Roma, Mayo

    Turkey Sub

    12

    Turkey, Swiss, Romaine, Roma, Mayo

    Ham Sub

    12

    Ham, Colby, Romaine, Roma, Mayo

    Pizza Sub

    13

    Salami, Pepperoni, Ham, Our Pizza Cheese Blend, Pizza Sauce, Mushrooms

    Italian Sub

    13

    Salami, Ham, Romaine, Roma, Provolone, Red Onion, Banana Pepper Rings, Italian Dressing

    Calzones

    Like a U. P Pizza Pasty!

    Cheese

    12

    Toppings are $0.50 and meats are $1.00

    Salads

    Fresh Made Daily

    Garden

    13

    Romaine, Tomato, Carrot, Croutons, and Assorted Dressings available

    Caesar

    13

    Romaine, Parmesan, Croutons, Caesar Dressing

    Greek

    14

    Romaine, Spinach, Black Olive, Onion, Roasted Red Pepper, Banana Pepper, Feta, and Assorted Dressings available

    Delivery within 10 miles is only $4.99! Please tip your delivery driver as they are working hard to bring the freshest pie to you. Thank You!

    Visit Us

    Special Requests?

    Do you have dietary concerns? Questions about an upcoming event? Drop us a line, and we'll get back to you soon.

    Bay Pizzeria

    100 South Cedar Street, Suttons Bay, Michigan 49682, United States

    (231) 866-4494

    Hours

    Today

    Closed

    Contact Us

    Attach Files
    Attachments (0)

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Cancel

    Connect With Us

    Copyright © 2025 Bay Pizzeria - All Rights Reserved.

    Powered by

    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions

    This website uses cookies.

    We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

    Accept